Brazil's prisons stand at 157% of capacity

Brazil's Supreme Court has ruled the state must compensate prisoners held in overcrowded conditions, in a decision that could lead to an avalanche of legal claims but is unlikely to help address the underlying causes of the country's prison crisis.

The ruling came as the result of a legal claim made by an ex-prisoner, who sued the state for compensation after spending his sentence in an overcrowded facility.

The nine judges all agreed that the state was responsible for damage to the claimant's dignity as it had failed to provide minimum levels of infrastructure, sanitary conditions and healthcare, reported Globo.

However, the court was split on the issue of financial compensation. Those in favor awarded the prisoner 2,000 reales -- approximately $645 -- in damages.

The judges who voted against the claim argued that financial compensation was an impractical solution as it could lead to a huge financial burden on the state due to the number of potential cases. Instead, they said, the court should explore alternatives such as reducing sentences, according to Globo.

InSight Crime Analysis

There is little doubt over the validity of the Brazilian prisoner's claim, as the treatment of inmates in Brazil's penitentiary system clearly violates their rights and the state's obligations to the prison population.

However, paying financial compensation to the inmate could amount to opening a pandora's box of legal claims. In Brazil, the prison system stands at 157 percent of its capacity, according to the Institute for Criminal Policy Research, meaning the majority of the country's more than 622,000 inmates could have a legitimate claim to compensation.

SEE ALSO: InDepth: Prisons

The crisis in Brazil's prisons has reached a critical point, with prison battles leaving over 130 inmates dead in January as gangs fight for supremacy in the institutions. Overcrowding is at the heart of the crisis, as it makes prisoner control of facilities all but inevitable because the guards are overrun.

Rather than getting bogged down in compensating the prisoners it has failed, the state's time and resources would be better directed toward tackling the underlying causes of overcrowding; a lack of investment in infrastructure, overuse of pretrial detention and hardline populist security laws.

Investigations

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
Prev Next

El Salvador Prisons and the Battle for the MS13’s Soul

El Salvador Prisons and the Battle for the MS13’s Soul

El Salvador's prison system is the headquarters of the country's largest gangs. It is also where one of these gangs, the MS13, is fighting amongst itself for control of the organization.

'MS13 Members Imprisoned in El Salvador Can Direct the Gang in the US'

'MS13 Members Imprisoned in El Salvador Can Direct the Gang in the US'

Special Agent David LeValley headed the criminal division of the Federal Bureau of Investigation's (FBI) Washington office until last November 8. While in office, he witnessed the rise of the MS13, the Barrio 18 (18th Street) and other smaller gangs in the District of Columbia as well...

Homicides in Guatemala: Conclusions and Recommendations

Homicides in Guatemala: Conclusions and Recommendations

Olfato. It is a term used quite often in law enforcement and judicial circles in Central America (and other parts of the world as well). It refers to the sixth sense they have as they see a crime scene, investigate a murder or plow through the paperwork...

Where Chaos Reigns: Inside the San Pedro Sula Prison

Where Chaos Reigns: Inside the San Pedro Sula Prison

In San Pedro Sula's jailhouse, chaos reigns. The inmates, trapped in their collective misery, battle for control over every inch of their tight quarters. Farm animals and guard dogs roam free and feed off scraps, which can include a human heart. Every day is visitors' day, and...

Homicides in Guatemala: Analyzing the Data

Homicides in Guatemala: Analyzing the Data

In the last decade, homicides in Guatemala have obeyed a fairly steady pattern. Guatemala City and some of its surrounding municipalities have the greatest sheer number of homicides. Other states, particularly along the eastern border have the highest homicide rates. Among these are the departments of Escuintla...

Colombia's Mirror: War and Drug Trafficking in the Prison System

Colombia's Mirror: War and Drug Trafficking in the Prison System

Colombia's prisons are a reflection of the multiple conflicts that have plagued the country for the last half-century. Paramilitaries, guerrillas and drug trafficking groups have vied for control of the jails where they can continue to manage their operations on the outside. Instead of corralling these forces...

The Fixer and El Salvador's Missed Opportunity

The Fixer and El Salvador's Missed Opportunity

In the photograph, they are both smiling. In the foreground, on the left hand side, a man in a short-sleeved buttoned white shirt, jeans and a metal watch, holds a bottle of water in his right hand. He laughs heartily. He is Herbert Saca. On the right...

Homicides in Guatemala: Introduction, Methodology, and Major Findings

Homicides in Guatemala: Introduction, Methodology, and Major Findings

When violence surged in early 2015 in Guatemala, then-President Otto Pérez Molina knew how to handle the situation: Blame the street gangs. 

Homicides in Guatemala: Collecting the Data

Homicides in Guatemala: Collecting the Data

When someone is murdered in Guatemala, police, forensic doctors and government prosecutors start making their way to the crime scene and a creaky, antiquated 20th century bureaucratic machine kicks into gear. Calls are made. Forms are filled out by hand, or typed into computers, or both. Some...

The Lucky ‘Kingpin’: How ‘Chepe Diablo’ Has (So Far) Ridiculed Justice

The Lucky ‘Kingpin’: How ‘Chepe Diablo’ Has (So Far) Ridiculed Justice

José Adán Salazar Umaña is the only Salvadoran citizen currently on the US government's Kingpin List. But in his defense, Salazar Umaña claims is he is an honorable businessman who started his career by exchanging money along the borders between Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras. He does...